Diet and behaviour - could diet be affecting your
child?
TV and newspapers often tell us that changing a child’s diet can improve
their behaviour, improve their concentration, and even make them more
intelligent.
Have you seen a connection between your child’s diet and their
behaviour?
Some carers can easily identify particular foods or drinks that clearly
make their child ‘hyperactive’, disruptive or irritable. For example you might
notice that after eating a certain brand of crisps, or drinking a certain drink,
their behaviour changes for the worse.
Other carers find it useful to keep a diary of the foods and drinks their
child has eaten, and a diary of their behaviour throughout the day.
Looking back at this over a period of a couple of weeks, they can then
identify particular patterns in their child’s behaviour that might be related to
certain foods or drinks, or to other things such as not having much exercise, or
when they are worrying about something such as a school activity or
class.
For many children, their diet does not have an effect on their behaviour,
for some though, there are obvious foods that affect them.
E-numbers and other food additives
E-numbers are food additives, and their safety is regulated by the
government. E-numbers include natural and synthetic additives. For example
E300 is ascorbic acid, a form of vitamin C.
Some people identify particular E-numbers that affect their child’s
mood or behaviour. These could be colourings, flavour enhancers, antioxidants,
preservatives or sweeteners.
Additives that have been linked to increased hyperactivity in some
children by scientific studies are:
- E102 – Tartrazine – A yellow colouring sometimes found in drinks and
lollies
- E110 – Sunset yellow FcF, Orange Yellow S – A yellow colouring
sometimes found in squash drinks, sweets and jelly
- E122 – Azorubine,
Carmoisine - A red colouring, sometimes found in sweets and jelly and
desserts
- E124 - Ponceau 4R, Cochineal Red – A red colouring, sometimes
found in jelly and desserts
- E211 – sodium benzoate – a preservative
sometimes found in sauces, pickles, meat products and squash drinks.
The scientific study does not show that all children are made more
hyperactive by these additives, only that some were.
Other additives that some carers have reported affect their child
include:
- Other colourings (E100-E199)
- E621 Monosodium glutamate (MSG) a
flavour enhancer often found in crisps
- E951 Aspartame, a sweetener used in
Diet or No Added Sugar drinks and yoghurts
- Flavourings – these do not have
E-numbers
- Caffeine – stimulant found in cola drinks, “energy” drinks, tea,
coffee and chocolate
Other foods
Some people report that certain foods or food groups affect them or their
child e.g. a specific fruit juice, milk, sugar.
If you notice a definite change in your child’s behaviour when having a
particular food, it may be advisable to reduce their intake of it, but it is
important not to cut nutritious foods out of a child’s diet without a suitable
replacement e.g. cutting out milk can lead to calcium deficiency, cutting out
wheat can lead to weight loss or constipation.
If you do decide cut out nutritious foods from your child’s diet in the
long-term, you should ask your GP, practice nurse or paediatrician to refer your
child to a registered dietitian, who can check your child is getting a balanced
and adequate diet.
Trial food exclusions
If you cannot identify any particular foods that are affecting your child’s
behaviour but still suspect that it is linked to their diet, you could try
excluding some foods for a few days to see if their behaviour improves. For
example, you may wish to have a week where your child has no drinks other than
water, no sweets, chocolate or crisps.
Keep a diary again to see if their
behaviour changes and then slowly reintroduce the foods one at a time to see if
it is one particular food that affect their behaviour or mood.
So what should my child eat for a healthy mind and
body?
The scientific evidence suggests that eating regular meals, keeping well
hydrated and a healthy balanced diet is the best way to fuel your child for
optimal mental and behavioural performance. Regular physical activity or
exercise is also important.
Fish, fish oils and omega 3s
Omega 3 fatty acids (omega 3) are proven to improve brain development in
under-5s and protect against heart disease in adulthood. There is research
being done to see if they help with learning and behaviour.
The government recommends that we all should get omega 3 from eating 2
portions of fish a week including one serving of oily fish.
Boys can have up to four portions of oily fish a week, but it's best to
limit girls no more than two portions of oily fish a week (this is to do with
toxins that are sometimes present in oily fish that could affect unborn babies
in high doses).
Avoid giving children shark, swordfish and marlin. This is because these
fish contain relatively high levels of mercury, which might affect a child's
developing nervous system.
Examples of omega-3-rich oily fish are: Mackerel, Kippers, Pilchards,
Trout, Salmon, Sardines, Herring, Eel, Whitebait, Anchovies, Swordfish, Bloater,
Cacha, Carp, Hilsa, Jack fish, Katla, Orange roughy, Pangas, Sprats, fresh or
frozen Tuna (omega 3 oils are extracted in tinning in the UK).
If your
child does not eat fish there are other foods containing omega 3s:
- dark green leafy vegetables
- wholegrain cereal products, e.g.
granary bread
- linseeds/flax, walnuts, pecans, peanuts or almonds (avoid
whole nuts in children under 5 years or if your child is at risk of
allergies)
- omega 3 enriched foods, e.g. Columbus eggs, some margarines,
some milks
- Olive oil, Rapeseed/Canola oil, linseed/flax oil or walnut
oil
If your child does not like oily fish or any of the foods listed above,
then they may benefit from a fish oil or plant based omega 3 oil supplement.
Consult your doctor before taking a supplement if your child is on
medication or has a medical condition such as epilepsy or haemophilia.
There have been some studies to investigate whether high doses of omega 3
oils as a supplement can help children with their concentration at school and
even improve the symptoms of children with attention defecit hyperactivity
disorder (ADHD) or autistic spectrum disorders (ASD). These studies are as yet
inconclusive, and it is not clear what precise dose of omega 3 is needed, and
what balance of essential fats (known as EPA and DHA). Researchers feel that
these high doses take 3 months of daily supplements before their full effects
are seen. High dose supplements can be quite expensive.
There are many different omega 3 and fish oil supplements on the market.
When choosing a supplement watch out that:
- It is suitable for the age of your child
- It is not too high in
vitamin A as this can become toxic in large amounts, especially in
children
- It has Vitamin E (tocopherols) to help the body to use the omega 3
and improve the supplement’s shelf life.
- It is a reputable UK brand, as all
fish oils supplements in the UK have to have been purified to reduce
pollutants
Acknowledgements:
Some information adapted from leaflets by dietitians at West Middlesex
University Hospital, with permission
Page first published:September 17th 2006, last updated: November 5th
2007.
Click
here to download this information as a pdf:
Could diet be affecting my child's
behaviour